Q. A, the son of X and Y was indebted to B in the amounted of P10M. Should the amount be brought to collation if X and Y paid the same? (Solved)
1. No, because it is the duty of the parents to support a child;
2. Yes, because it is a donation inter vivos made to A, a compulsory heir, hence, an advance inheritance;
3. No, because A is merely indebted to X and Y;
4. No, because it was not gratuitously given.
- b. Yes, because it is a donation inter vivos made to A, a compulsory heir, hence, an advance inheritance;